School life / One careers program in a school library, spring 2006
Funeral Director, Wig Maker or Lighthouse Keeper: Try Again
The careers quiz told our daughter she should be a florist. I had other plans, her school login and a whole night.

In the 1980s, BBC Scotland reported, an estimated four million pupils filled in the Jiig-Cal careers questionnaire, had their answers driven by van to a computer at Edinburgh University with a whole building to itself, and waited weeks to be told they would be wig makers or lighthouse keepers. Its inventor, Jim Closs, stood by it: “I am sure we had some pupils who were offended when they got funeral director on their printouts, but are now actually practising funeral directors.”
I was one of the offended. Mine said tree surgeon. I have never forgiven a tree.
Last week our daughter, who is in Year 10, did the modern version on a school laptop. It took eleven minutes and no van. It suggested she become a florist. She was delighted. I was not. I had not driven her to Saturday maths for six years to produce a florist.
That night I logged in as her. I am not proud of this. I did have a precedent. Phill, blogging for the careers platform Kloodle in 2020, admitted to running an older program, Kudos, hundreds of times with different answers, tailoring them to whatever job he fancied that week. His pilot week went: “Work well at heights? Yup, absolutely!” I had the same method and a stronger motive. Do you enjoy working outdoors? Never. Do you mind getting dirty? Very much. Are you comfortable with responsibility? As of tonight, she is.
By 1am I had run it eleven times and barrister had not come up once. Twice it offered actuary, which I then had to look up. Once, when I said she liked animals, it offered pig farming, which I took personally. At 1.40, out of spite, I said she disliked everything, and it suggested lighthouse keeper.
The annoying thing is that these machines are sometimes right. One Reddit user remembers Jiig-Cal suggesting cartographer, fashion designer or florist, now works as a professional seamstress and wardrobe assistant, and reckons it was not far off. Mr Closs said his own daughter became a teacher, one of the options Jiig-Cal had given her. I have yet to find one that suggested barrister to a girl who wanted to arrange flowers.
At breakfast our daughter opened the laptop and found fourteen completed questionnaires. She scrolled through them in silence, eating toast. Then she read out the last one, the one I had answered at 2am, most honestly, as myself.
Tree surgeon.
Sources
- Careers advisors should teach meta learning, Kloodle, 15 April 2020
- Stuart Nicolson, The computer that predicted the future, BBC Scotland, 19 June 2008
- Jamie-Starr-5816, comment in Did you do a computerised career suggestion at school?, r/AskUK, December 2022 discussion
Notes from the School Gates is a light-hearted column: home scenes and family characters are invented; schools and public facts are real. About the column